We’d like a nationwide day for unity, not division
Australia is the one nation that takes the start of colonisation as its nationwide day, writes Berthold. Says all of it. Vic Alhadeff, Kirribilli
New developments go away chilly metropolis of their shadow
I shudder once I hear the phrases “worldwide design competitors” utilized to public land in Sydney (“Station redesign prompts radical various”, January 24). That’s as a result of the phrase, coupled with Sydney’s so-called planning regime – a.okay.a. advert hoc interference from events – has given us such grotesqueries as Barangaroo: that phallic forest obliterating a as soon as placing and distinctive foreshore.
Now a “huge land deck coated by parkland” is proposed close to Central Station, to be paid for by constructing high-rise towers on historic and delightful Prince Alfred Park – for generations a standard tenting website, extra not too long ago a Sydney landmark, liked and utilized by households, walkers, train junkies, commuters, swimmers and cyclists. The proponent’s spokesman admits the agency’s plan could be “contentious”. Can I say, sir, you’ve no thought how bloody contentious. Geraldine O’Brien, Redfern
Buying and selling inexperienced house by no means works: put the 15 towers on a land deck over the practice traces and hold the dear open inexperienced house at Prince Alfred Park. The architects are already speaking about solely holding an “avenue of fig bushes and historic buildings”. It takes 10 to 40 years for bushes to mature as is clear at Barangaroo park and the historic buildings are vital to our historical past and are irreplaceable. Helen Simpson, Curl Curl
I can’t imagine it. The NSW authorities has spent hundreds of thousands making Central extra nice with Central stroll. It plans good inexperienced areas between Railway Sq. and the station. Nevertheless it additionally needs to bury the platforms underneath a deck which can flip many of the station right into a dungeon the place you won’t be able to see the clock tower. A dungeon the place heritage steam specials can’t run. The place commuters and travellers can’t see the solar – or the celebrities whereas ready to your practice to depart. The cynic says in me that the one purpose for placing it underground is to earn a living for the Transport Belongings Holding Entity. Are these proposals for the good thing about the travelling public?
So as to add insult to harm, the plan additionally proposes destroy the adjoining Prince Alfred Park. There may be sufficient excessive rise already. Go away Central alone. Grant Robinson, Springwood
Any authorities that contemplates consuming the little remaining parkland in Sydney needs to be despatched to Siberia, all the lot. I’m completely satisfied to contribute. Sydney and NSW desperately want somebody with imaginative and prescient, no more wind-funnelling towers and a koala-less countryside. Moderately than searching for recommendation from the large finish of city, let’s strive Clover Moore and her group – the one ones with their integrity intact. Ashley Berry, Toolijooa
PM speaks clearly on the Voice
Shrinking assist for the Indigenous Voice to parliament is heartbreaking however not stunning (“Voice assist falls as debate heats up”, January 24). Sadly, it’ll proceed to fall for so long as its proponents blur the element and rely merely on goodwill and a way of honest play to claim their argument.
Anthony Albanese has been passionate in making the case for constitutional recognition of Indigenous Australians so cruelly missed when the nation’s “delivery certificates” was drafted within the final years of the nineteenth century. However whereas his type of phrases gives for a Voice, there’s no overriding symbolic assertion of inclusion declaring that Indigenous Australians type the keystone of our nationwide polity. The slim concentrate on the Voice itself – a sensible thought however nebulous in the way it would possibly work – just isn’t accompanied by any hovering imaginative and prescient. There isn’t a try and appropriate the unique constitutional injustice.
On the matter of element, the prime minister’s soothing mantra is that there’s loads of it “on the market” – Australians simply want to hunt it out and all will develop into clear. That is removed from sure. I doubt that any however a small minority of Australians are sufficiently constitutionally literate to make an evaluation of the proposal on provide or to know the nuanced place that the equipment of the Voice itself will likely be constructed later when it’s debated and legislated within the parliament. Precept first and element later will appear an enormous ask, even when the precept itself is sound.
Critics of the Voice have been fast to use the inevitable cautionary doubts and uncertainties of Australians when they’re requested to contemplate proposals to vary or amend the Structure. This means failures of technique and advocacy. John Thompson, Darlinghurst
There isn’t a doubt Peter Dutton is taking part in political video games concerning the Voice and polling would recommend it’s having an affect.
The prime minister is turning into more and more entangled by consistently referring voters to a 272-page report for element, a bridge too far for the common voter.
When questioned on the legislative suggestions throughout the report he refuses to endorse them. He must reset the talk. Mike Kenneally, Manly
Well being system nonetheless struggling
Whereas the promise by Labor of a rise in funding for ladies’s well being centres is an efficient factor, it could have way more affect to extend funding for all well being centres and to extend pay for these important employees (“Leaders step up election guarantees for ladies’s well being, home violence”, January 24). We’d like extra basic modifications to the well being system, not vote-grabbing tweaks. Robyn Thomas, Wahroonga
Toll highway roundabout
The federal government makes use of taxpayers’ cash to construct costly motorways, then leases the roads to personal corporations who make huge earnings by charging these taxpayers to make use of the roads (“Half 1,000,000 Sydney drivers to entry toll aid scheme”, January 24). Then the federal government makes use of extra taxpayers’ cash to reimburse those self same taxpayers for the highway tolls. I’m not an economist however from the viewpoint of the taxpayers there appears to me to be one thing flawed with this method. Judy Christian, Fort Hill
The rationale we have now an “costly toll system” on our roads is as a result of the system, arrange by the present Coalition authorities in NSW, is one which ensures excessive earnings to Transurban, an abroad firm which now owns them. The unique thought was that customers could be paying for these earnings, nonetheless, as they’ve now reached astronomical ranges for such customers, and there may be an election looming, the earnings will now be paid by the state as a complete. Brenton McGeachie, Queanbeyan West
Blinded by massive bucks
The editorial mentioned the financial advantages of closing the Sydney Harbour Bridge completely for seven hours was a accountable use of the general public asset, whereas the closing of 1 lane for 25 minutes by a local weather disaster advocate to boost consciousness of the hazard we’re in was an irresponsible act (“Bridge closure will carry extra advantages than inconvenience”, January 24).
Final November, the CSIRO launched a state of the local weather report which confirmed the rise in greenhouse gases within the environment will result in international temperature rises of as much as 4.5 levels. We’re taking part in a lethal recreation of rooster with ourselves.
The local weather activist faces 15 months in jail. The movie firm has been subsidised by the NSW and federal governments to the tune of $45 million. There seems to be one thing flawed with our priorities. Simon Probability, Richmond Hill
Brief flight, lengthy wait
If solely flying between Melbourne and Sydney took simply over an hour as your correspondent claims (Letters, January 24). Add on safety screening, ready for bags, the inevitable delays if not cancellations, journey between the airport and the CBD, and you may simply take as much as 4 hours. Kate Lumley, Hurlstone Park
The present difficulty of the transition to cashless commerce has but to acknowledge the precise quantities individuals pay when making a digital transaction (Letters, January 24).
If a retailer provides an additional 1 per cent to the whole when a card is used for fee, this payment can develop into a big further value if a big sum is concerned. A $15 buy is charged an additional 15 cents, however to purchase one thing with the identical card for $1500 sees the fee soar to $15 for a similar service.
I don’t think about that the processing value to the retailer or the financial institution will increase with the acquisition worth.
It’s disingenuous for companies to indicate that giant surcharges are the results of banking follow. William Galton, Hurstville Grove
Put bot on the spot
If an educator thinks ChatGPT might need written an project, why don’t they simply ask it (“If AI has all of the solutions, universities want new questions”, January 24). It has no purpose to lie – certainly it may well’t, actually – and may little question detect its personal authorship higher than anybody. Andrew Taubman, Queens Park
Ageism lives on
The one purpose that your correspondent finds it baffling as to how somebody may give their finest of their 80s and 90s is as a result of he’s clearly not there but (Letters, January 24). Judith Bennett, Umina Seaside
Your correspondent’s letter is a blatant expression of age discrimination. If he had been an employer he would threat being liable to prosecution underneath the Age Discrimination Act. I’d relatively our governing individuals be chosen on correct benefit than by arbitrary labels like “ageing”, Gen X, Gen Y and many others. Age and youth shouldn’t be set towards one another on this prejudiced method. Bob Hinchcliffe, Wahroonga
No relish for pickles
Fascinating studying about what’s or just isn’t an Aussie burger (“An ode to the Aussie burger”, January 24). Nevertheless, the ever-present pickle, whereas not talked about within the article, appeared twice within the images of an “Aussie burger”. Should we perpetually be assailed by the American pickle in burger assessments? Simply go away them out and keep away from the offensive protect. Greg Crawford, Leppington
You may experiment with as many fillings as you want with my Aussie burger, simply miss that tasteless, salty, chewy, plastic beef patty. Kevin Eadie, Drummoyne
The digital view
On-line remark from one of many tales that attracted essentially the most reader suggestions yesterday on smh.com.au
‘Sheer terror’: Rosemary’s horror at her $65,000 robo-debt
From Randroid: ″No matter your political leanings, no matter your voting intentions, it’s actually arduous to imagine that key ministers didn’t perceive what they had been doing right here.″
- To submit a letter to The Sydney Morning Herald, electronic mail firstname.lastname@example.org. Click on right here for tips about the best way to submit letters.
The Opinion e-newsletter is a weekly wrap of views that may problem, champion and inform. Enroll right here.